Providing Project Report Feedback & an Evaluation – BCM325

This blog post was written as part of BCM 325 – Future Cultures, as studied as part of my Digital & Social Media major at the University of Wollongong.


Context for those who might not be studying BCM325, we are each undertaking a project with a central focus on “the future”. We have now provided a progress report on these projects (here is mine), and are now providing feedback on three other student’s reports, and evaluating that feedback.


Project One: The Future of Care Work

Short Summary:

Alana is creating a short series of podcasts and a website to embed in the podcasts alongside their transcripts. Her project is focusing on how the care work industry may shift and change with developments in technology. You can find Alana’s progress report here.

My Feedback:

Hi Alana! Your DA sounds interesting and it’s a really important topic! It’s great to hear that you’ve got your website design together and based on your timeline you were planning on uploading your first podcast episode! I’d have loved if you’d shared a link to the website so I could check out what you’ve got so far so I could provide better feedback!

It’s a shame that you haven’t received much feedback on your project. I’m not sure how much you’re interested in exploring what opinions and predictions current aged care workers have for the future of the field, but maybe you’ll be able to get something if you reach out directly to someone in the field? I’m sure they could have some very valuable insights. Although considering the current health emergency they may not have the time to respond before the end of semester…

I’ve found two articles written by aged care workers which include some mentions of how technology might effect the industry, such as using VR technology to help delay the onset of dementia, or having administrative duties be completed more quickly and efficiently by AI so that there’s more time to help patients meet their social needs. I’ll link the articles below, and I hope you find something useful in them!

https://www.agedcareguide.com.au/talking-aged-care/innovative-technology-hits-aged-care-head-on
https://signpostlms.com.au/the-changing-face-of-australian-aged-care-in-2019-and-beyond/


Project Two: The Future of Surveillance

Short Summary:

Mikayla is developing a series of videos exploring the current state of surveillance, and what surveillance may be like in the future. You can find Mikayla’s progress report here.

My Feedback:

Hi Mikayla! I’m really liking what you’ve done with your project so far! Your videos are fantastic in terms of their information, and the production levels are pretty good! You’ve clearly put a lot of research and thought into your videos, both in terms of surveillance itself and in futurist thinking! One thing I think that could help improve your project even more, would be to include some of your sources in your videos (or at least in your video descriptions) to increase the credibility of your videos and so viewers can read more on the topic if they want to.

In terms of the impact the pandemic and the COVIDSafe app might have on surveillance in Australia, I’ve seen a LOT of skepticism and wariness around security and privacy concerns around the app, so increased surveillance does seem to be a concern for the population. Evidently, there a lot of cases where the app just doesn’t work as it’s supposed to, such as not working on older phone models, or not working correctly on iPhones (links below). Apple and Google have been working on their own contact-tracing technology, and have received inquiries from various countries’ authorities looking to use their tech. Make of that what you will, but to me this might be an indication of surveillance becoming less government run and more corporate run in the future, which I find quit unsettling. You might be able to make some commentary on this in your third video?
Hope you’ve found something useful in my feedback!

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/may/15/covid-safe-app-australia-how-download-does-it-work-australian-government-covidsafe-covid19-tracking-downloads
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-04-26/coronavirus-tracing-app-covidsafe-apple-iphone-covid-19/12187448
https://venturebeat.com/2020/05/21/23-countries-seek-access-to-apple-and-googles-contact-tracing-technology/


Project Three: A Cybernetic Church

Short Summary:

With the risks surrounding social gatherings in the time of COVID-19, Ethan is working with his church to digitize and livestream through the duration of the pandemic and beyond, in order to make its services more accessible and maintain its community when there are difficulties in physical attendance. You can find Ethan’s progress report here.

Hi Ethan! This seems like such a cool project and I’m glad it’s going well! With the way you’ve kept track of and analysed engagement from your viewers you seem to have a good idea of what you’re doing!

With the loosening of restrictions on social gatherings lately, it’s possible your church could decide to reopen in-person gatherings soon-ish. You seem to be intending to maintain the live sessions after the pandemic, so I’m wondering how the online gatherings might change when the in-person ones restart? It’s easy for an in-person community to feel connected and engaged with each other and reasonably easy for an online community to connect with each other, but it’s not always easy to have the separate groups connect with each other. I’ve found that digital live-viewers tend to be a bit neglected when they’re tuning into an otherwise mostly in-person gathering, so you might need to keep that in mind and figure out a way to keep everyone connected.

I’m not 100% sure how your church operates and how much will be relevant to you, but below I’m linking you to an article on some of the changes churches might see post-coronavirus such as smaller gatherings, and some potential changes to some traditions where one church goer might give a handshake or a hug. I don’t know how many of these changes will eventuate, but it might be a good idea to keep them in mind.

https://www.christianpost.com/voices/what-will-the-post-coronavirus-church-look-like.html


Feedback Evaluation and Reflection

As with the feedback I provided on several fellow students project pitches, I am once again realizing the importance of communicating the specifics of your work when looking to receive feedback, and I am left a bit nervous in the effectiveness and suitability of my feedback.

For example, I’m reasonably confident in the quality of feedback I was able to provide Mikayla for her surveillance focused project, as she was very clear in the communication of her project and was able to share the work she had completed thus far. In knowing the specific focus on surveillance in Australia and how the pandemic may influence surveillance, I was able to provide her with specific sources and examples regarding contact tracing apps, which is directly relevant to her project.

Conversely, I’m less confident in the relevance of my feedback to Alana’s care work project. I wasn’t able to access a prototype or access the work she had completed so far, which somewhat limits my understanding of her project. However, since she had communicated an issue with receiving feedback or having questions on the topic answered, I did offer some advice which I hope would help lessen her frustrations in this area. But in case my suggestion ultimately doesn’t increase the feedback she receives, I also provided two sources written by those in the care work field which she may find helpful.

Ethan’s project regarding moving church gathering online on the other hand, is one that I understand the specifics off it quite readily, but struggle to connect with due to unfamiliarity with organized religion. Of course, I did conduct some research to uncover some difficulties his church might face in the future due to this pandemic and was sure to share these with him. I, personally, am not able to provide feedback specifically suited for church gatherings, but I was able to provide some more generally applicable feedback regarding the challenges of maintaining a community split across digital and physical spaces, once in-person services resume.

Overall, I’m a bit happier with the quality of feedback I was able to provide for these progress reports than I was able to provide for project pitches earlier in the semester. Hopefully, my fellow students will have found something useful in my feedback which they can use to make their projects even better than they already are.


.

.

Image proof of the feedback comments, just in the event that they are not accessible in the future for any reason.

One thought on “Providing Project Report Feedback & an Evaluation – BCM325

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s